some thoughts on Brooklyn's newest hub for indie comics

Promo poster by Ronald Wimberly

Before I start though, know that my criticality comes from a place of genuine care for the health of the scene itself, so treat this as a diagnostic, not a diagnosis.

And a disclosure: I’m very grateful to my friends and pals on the organizing committee for bringing me on to DJ the awards show afterparty. We had a great time!

With that established, Duke’s opinion is my opinion. And our opinion is the opinion of the handful of Black attendees and exhibitors I talked to this past weekend.

Duke Stephens's avatar

brooklyn comics events need more black people imo

“This was a poor first impression,” one attendee said. “I won’t be coming back.”

“I expected to see more Black artists at a show about Brooklyn artists,” another told me.

“This must be for the other Brooklyn,” said another, gesturing around the post-gentrified Williamsburg.

photo of me by Ami Cai

The reason why this show attracts scrutiny is because of how heavily it identifies with the culture and imagery of the borough itself—“BODEGA,” chopped cheeses, and a spirit of grit and city pride colored by the contributions of Black and brown New Yorkers. Yet on a floor of well over a hundred exhibitors, there were maybe five Black creators. Hell, one guy even pulled up last-minute just to fill in for someone else who couldn’t make it.

What gets me though, is that every single Black artist I talked to but one was from out of town. And I did not meet one person who was Black and native to here. For a show that reps Brooklyn this hard, they more or less imported their Black representation from other cities and looked over the good folks living and making work in the borough.

I’m a veteran observer. I be looking and seeing. So this strikes a chord with my specific corner of the scene, because we’ve been doing this for over ten years, and we only ever see each other represented on the con circuit. Across these years, I can reliably expect the same thing: one obligatory token guest, and the four or five familiar names. All prolific, all talented, but all the same. It’s as if there’s no new blood coming in, or that nobody is looking across Broadway or Eastern Parkway—shoot, let alone beyond PLG—for artists who don’t come from their own understanding of the city, its culture, and comics.

And it’s not like folks aren’t trying. Among the people I chatted with were a number of local artists who had applied and didn’t make it. This is still a diagnostic, so I’m not accusing anyone of discrimination. But it is a blind spot, and it’s endemic to the entire indie comics circuit of this particular flavor. Black and brown artists in this scene deserve more than to be valued only for their name and proximity recognition, or their manual and cultural labor. A show as new as BEC, opened a brief window to show that our scene has cultivated a deeper, more outwardly focused and curious taste, but the work continues.

And this can include BODEGA, the organizing body, partnering and scouting from other local shows in the offseason. Take BICS, their mission statement clearly commits to "highlight[ing] the vast array of talented, and perhaps underrepresented, creators in the NY metro area." There’s Printed Matter’s Art Book Fair, "celebrating the full breadth of the art publishing community". And Black Zine Fair’s explicit focus on showcasing the myriad talents from across the diaspora.

Ultimately though, it has to start with interest and a genuine baseline commitment.